South Carolina Still Prosecuting Consenting Adults

Jane covered this news but I had to examine it here, too.

From greenvilleonline.com comes this coverage of this terrible story...

LAURENS COUNTY — A father and daughter are charged with incest in Laurens County after a child was born, police say.

So we charge people with crimes now because of births?

Investigators in Laurens County were looking into an alleged sexual abuse incident when they learned that Katlyn Edwards had given birth to a child after being impregnated by her biological father, James Travis Brown, the Laurens County Sheriff’s Office said in a statement.

Consanguinamory shouldn't be a crime.

“During the investigation, we learned (Edwards and Brown) had been in a consensual relationship when she became pregnant,” the sheriff’s office said.

STOP. Consensual. That should have ended things.

According to the sheriff’s office, both Edwards and Brown claimed their relationship was “consensual and mutual” during investigators’ interviews. 

“Investigators also found other evidence to support their claim that the relationship was consensual,” the sheriff’s office said.

Are we clear that it was CONSENSUAL??? The problem is, people confess all of the time because they don't think consensual sex would be a crime, but it still is in some places. So don't talk! Use your right to remain silent.

I wonder what the evidence is? My guess is either texts or video. Be careful, lovers!

Edwards was arrested on Monday without incident and taken to the Laurens County detention center. She is not currently listed as being jailed.

She shouldn't have been arrested in the first place!

The child died at a medical facility in Charleston, South Carolina, according to the statement. 

How sad.

“It is beyond my comprehension how this could take place between a father and daughter,” Laurens County Sheriff Don Reynolds said.

Really? How long have you been in law enforcement? This happens all of the time, especially in reunion GSA situations. We don't know if this was a reunion situation, but their surnames are different. That could be for any number of reasons.

“At this time, I can’t confirm the baby died from complications related to incest, however we wonder if that’s the case."

Most children born to these relationships are healthy. Most children born with serious health problems in the US don't have those problems are a result of consanguinity.

"We are working with medical professionals and the Solicitors Office regarding that aspect of the investigation and will update everyone if there are any additional charges.”

Since they don't mention murder or signs of abuse, my guess is he's talking about prosecuting them for, essentially, having a genetic problem. Well guess what? If people in consanguinamorous relationships could feel confident in being completely honest with medical professionals, it is less likely that children will suffer with health problems. So we need to stop arresting and discriminating against them and, instead, offer services and study them so we can help people.

The Sheriff's press release is here. You can leave a comment on it. I sure did.

People of South Carolina and Laurens County in particular: Stop putting people in jail for sharing love and sex. There is no good reason to continue to persecute consenting adults for loving each other as they mutually agree.

To the persecuted defendants: So sorry what has been done to you, especially after losing a child. If you can, move someone better as soon as you can. There are countries that don't treat adult lovers are criminals, and you will also not be criminalized in New Jersey or Rhode Island.